Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Pixie Prissy's avatar

Gahhhh. I’m so confused. This is a 180 from what “A Midwestern Doctor” posts on this platform about DMSO. Oh, who to believe in these days of deception. 🤔

Adrian Pearson's avatar

Your logic that only a dirty product can come from a dirty process is false.

In the early days, penicillin, the world-changing antibiotic, was literally derived from mold that grew on old, dirty bread or food scraps in laboratory back rooms. The process looked (and was) unappetising and grimy by everyday hygiene standards. However, through careful extraction and purification, the powerful antibiotic was separated from the muck and became a life-saving medicine. If we used the same logic as the article, we would say: "Penicillin comes from dirty mold growing on dirty bread, so it must be a dirty and dangerous drug,” ignoring all the purification and testing that happens between process and product.

The rest of your article discusses all of the negative biological effects than can come from use of "a solvent". But your article is meant to be about one, specific, solvent - DMSO. Assuming all solvents have the same effects just because they are classified as solvents makes no sense. It's like saying, "All mushrooms are poisonous because some mushrooms are," ignoring the vast differences among them.

Ethanol (the alcohol in wine and beer) is a solvent and safe to drink in moderation. Methanol (wood alcohol), also a simple alcohol and a solvent, is extremely toxic and can cause blindness or death even in small quantities. Both are "alcohols" and both are "solvents", but their effects in the body differ dramatically.

To argue that DMSO is dangerous because "solvents" in general can be dangerous is like saying "You should never drink ethanol because methanol, also an alcohol, can kill you." This ignores the crucial chemical and biological distinctions between individual members of the group "solvent" (or "alcohol").

I don't have a dog in this fight by the way. I just prefer properly reasoned arguments.

787 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?